Kalo te përmbajtja
  • EN
  • SQ
  • IT
  • FR
  • ES
  • DE
  • EL
VA-NEWS VA-NEWS
  • Home
  • News
  • Opinion
  • Health
  • Technology
  • Sport
  • Lifestyle
  • Entertainment
  • Travel
LIVE
Navigation

VA-NEWS

  • Home
  • News
  • Opinion
  • Health
  • Technology
  • Sport
  • Lifestyle
  • Entertainment
  • Travel
Shortcuts
Home Latest
LIVE
Gjuha
  • EN
  • SQ
  • IT
  • FR
  • ES
  • DE
  • EL

Search news

  1. Kryefaqja
  2. Opinion
  3. Stop talking about the US ‘Jewish vote’. It’s not that simple | Judith Levine | The Guardian
Opinion

Stop talking about the US ‘Jewish vote’. It’s not that simple | Judith Levine | The Guardian

• October 9, 2026 • 7 min read • 👁 9
◉ WhatsApp 𝕏 X
News

Everybody wants the Jewish vote. As if there were one. Jews are educated, generally liberal. Although they comprise only about 2% of the electorate, they vote in high numbers, overwhelmingly for Democrats. In 2024, 79% chose Kamala Harris. They are also assumed to be steadfast friends of Israel, no matter what it does. Republicans, waging a fake war on antisemitism while courting white supremacists, consider Jews increasingly up for grabs.

Nationally, Jewish Americans are concentrated in a few bright blue spots. A 2020 map from the Jewish Electorate Institute showed a third of Jews living in 20 congressional districts – out of 435 – most of them in New York, New Jersey, California and (purple) Florida. Of these, only one sent a Republican to Washington.

Today, it’s two. Florida’s 21st district switched parties only after falling victim to redistricting in 2022. The other outlier has elected the pro-Israel, anti-immigration Republican Chris Smith every term since 1981. Why? The mapmakers’ explanation: New Jersey fourth district includes Lakewood, where half the residents are ultra-Orthodox – scrupulously, ceaselessly observant. Unsurprisingly, among white voters, regular religious service attendance is a big predictor of conservatism.

In other words, in Lakewood, Orthodox may be more salient that Jewish.

In fact, if pro-Israel candidates are looking for votes, even Jewish is no longer salient. White Evangelical Christians are more firmly supportive of Israel than American Jews. The US is home to the largest population of Christian Zionists in the world, numbering more than 30 million, a third of whom belong to Christians United for Israel, the largest Zionist organization is the US.

Read more:Vance wants voters to ‘give us another chance’. But he is cornered | Sidney Blumenthal | The Guardian

The Bible belt churches these people attend preach that the founding of Israel in 1948 was part of God’s plan to bring about the End Times, and the ongoing hostilities in the Middle East are the mayhem and destruction preceding the second coming of Christ (when nonbelievers – including Jews – will drown in the Lake of Fire).

While the American Israel Public Affairs Committee (Aipac) spends far more on political campaigns, Christians United for Israel is busy mobilizing its millions to grassroots action.

Meanwhile, a minority of American Jews now call themselves Zionists. A late-2025 Washington Post poll found that six in 10 believed Israel was committing war crimes in Gaza; four in 10 said the assault was genocide. And aside from the fiercest partisans, for many young Jews, Israel just isn’t that important.

The Gaza war figured large in the 2024 presidential elections, as the civilian death toll mounted and the Biden-Harris administration stood unwaveringly beside Israel. Now, even as the killing spreads to the West Bank and southern Lebanon, US voters are moving on. Affordability is the winning buzzword this cycle, at least for Democrats. Almost no one is thinking about foreign policy.

What about abortion? Climate change? Voting rights? The press, the pundits, and the mainstream party strategists keep behaving as if every Jew cares about Israel – and all Jews care about is Israel – and a candidate must be pro-Zionist or lose the elusive Jewish vote.

Read more:My Instagram reels addiction has ruined my ability to have a conversation. But can I get it back? | Hannah Ewens | The Guardian

We saw this during the campaign of the New York mayor, Zohran Mamdani. Forthright support for Palestinian self-determination had long been central to his politics, and to his appeal to progressives. But Mamdani was running for mayor, not president. His brilliant stroke was affordability – a theme that is easily understandable, widely relatable, and capable of making socialist solutions sound reasonable.

Nevertheless, from the moment he appeared, the press, from the New York Times op-ed page to college newspapers to the international Jewish press, made the election a referendum on Israel – and, more perniciously, on Islam.

Mamdani’s Democratic primary opponent, former governor Andrew Cuomo, attacked him with flagrant Islamophobia, conflating his critique of Israel with antisemitism and signalling that his faith was a danger to Jews.

The fearmongering did not defeat Mamdani.

Read more:Islamophobia is rising – and Britain’s politicians have been dangerously complacent in tackling it | Arun Kundnani | The Guardian

In the end, only a third of Jews voted for him; in Hasidic neighborhoods, 90% went for Cuomo. But progressive Jewish organizations including Jewish Voice for Peace and Jews for Racial and Economic Justice endorsed him. He won in almost every racial and class demographic and pulled in three-quarters of voters under 30.

What’s the lesson here? The youth vote – plus the Black vote, the Hispanic vote, the working-class vote, etc – plus good ideas and a great campaign put Mamdani over the top. Furthermore, an analysis by Good Authority concludes that no position on Israel, pro or con, is driving Jews out of the Democratic party.

Now Abdul El-Sayed, the Muslim Democrat running for Senate in Michigan, is shlepping the burden of this vaguely defined, perpetually disgruntled “Jewish vote”. After narrowly winning the primary, he apologized to members of the Jewish community for a statement he made after a Lebanese-born naturalized citizen rammed his truck into a large synagogue, injuring a guard.

The apology came after El-Sayed clumsily linked the man’s antisemitism to Israeli violence in Lebanon, saying: “Hurt people hurt people.” It was an inoffensive adage among, say, prison abolitionists. But to some Jews, it sounded as if El-Sayed felt more sympathy for the perpetrator than for his targeted victims.

The Republicans have taken advantage of these fissures, attacking El-Sayed with a combination of Islamophobia and the usual hypocritical condemnations of antisemitism. At their midterm “convention”, El-Sayed’s opponent Mike Rogers claimed, falsely, that the Democrat had ties to the Muslim Brotherhood. And while El-Sayed definitively distanced himself from the leftwing Israel critic Hasan Piker – a Twitch streamer the press began to cover obsessively – speaker after speaker hammered on the connection between the two men.

Read more:Paid influencers are everywhere in US politics. We need transparency | Martin J Riedl and Samuel Woolley | The Guardian

These tactics appear to be falling flat. A recent New York Times/Siena poll found that most Michiganders have never heard of Piker. The poll found that El-Sayed leads his opponent by 39 points among voters 44 and younger, who are far more critical of Israel’s policies than their elders. That generational split is also pronounced among Jews.

El-Sayed has the endorsements of JVP and IfNotNow, an organization that attracts many young Jews who are painfully rejecting their parents’ Zionism, as well as Vermont’s Jewish senator, Bernie Sanders. While Rogers has been collecting pledges of votes from Jewish Michiganders, more than 600 “Michigan Jews for Democracy”, including elected officials and rabbis, have signed a letter in support of El-Sayed.

Recently, Mamdani repeated his condemnation of Benjamin Netanyahu as a war criminal who should be arrested in advance of the Israeli prime minister’s visit to New York to address the UN. That revived Zionist fury toward the mayor, but Jews both supportive and critical of Israel – and Mamdani – held noisy rallies.

The reason for Mamdani to keep trying to speak to both sides is not to win the mythical Jewish vote. It is to make common cause with people who don’t want Israel swept into the sea but also cannot abide a Jewish ethnostate whose survival depends on occupation and apartheid.

Read more:UEFA, Concacaf call on Infantino to make $10m payments to all FIFA members

That said, if El-Sayed were the Islamist Jew-hater his enemies claim he is, it should be obvious to a lot more Jews. If it were obvious to a lot more Jews, Aipac would not have had to pour $32m – unsuccessfully – into Stevens’ campaign or contemplate pouring more into supporting Rogers in the general election.

And of course, the “Arab American” or “Muslim vote” is no more unanimous than the hypothetical Jewish vote.

To be frank, the whole discourse stinks. It boils down to “support the Muslim” or “support the Jew”, as if this were some ancient racial animosity – natural enemies “fighting”, as Trump said of the Palestinians and Israeli Jews, “for a thousand years”.

Not only is this contention untrue. Such thinking obviates politics, the effort to understand a problem and convince others that your solution is best. It is not good for the Jews – or for anyone. And it is deadly for a secular, pluralistic democracy.

Read also
Opinion

Firing a manager is often more about maintaining the illusion of control | Premier League | The Guardian

Opinion

The Guardian view on Jensen Huang’s affair: why did Trump ignore the warnings? | Editorial | The Guardian

Tags: #Abortion #Antisemitism #Benjamin netanyahu #Bernie Sanders #California #Democrats #Florida #Friends

Journalist

From the same category
  • Firing a manager is often more about maintaining the illusion of control | Premier League | The Guardian
  • The Guardian view on Jensen Huang’s affair: why did Trump ignore the warnings? | Editorial | The Guardian
  • ‘The light of dawn is on the horizon’: the best moments from US midterm victory speeches | Ted Widmer | The Guardian
  • Will Pete Hegseth be the blue tsunami’s next victim? | Arwa Mahdawi | The Guardian
  • The Guardian view on the AI backlash: Silicon Valley’s political power is cracking | Editorial | The Guardian
From the same tags
  • The Guardian view on Jensen Huang’s affair: why did Trump ignore the warnings? | Editorial | The Guardian
  • ‘The light of dawn is on the horizon’: the best moments from US midterm victory speeches | Ted Widmer | The Guardian
  • Will Pete Hegseth be the blue tsunami’s next victim? | Arwa Mahdawi | The Guardian
  • The Guardian view on the AI backlash: Silicon Valley’s political power is cracking | Editorial | The Guardian
  • Trump is soothing the midterms loss with what he loves best: interior design | Arwa Mahdawi | The Guardian
Më të lexuarat — 48h
  1. 01
    Football Gotham to play NWSL semi at 5K seat Icahn Stadium due to shoddy home field 11 lexime · 1 day ago
  2. 02
    Health Experts issue new recommendations for treating shift work disorder 8 lexime · 1 day ago
  3. 03
    Opinion The Guardian view on Jensen Huang’s affair: why did Trump ignore the warnings? | Editorial | The Guardian 5 lexime · 1 day ago
  4. 04
    Opinion Firing a manager is often more about maintaining the illusion of control | Premier League | The Guardian 1 lexime · 10 hours ago
  5. 05
    Health Could longer exposure to estrogen benefit brain health? 1 lexime · 9 hours ago
  6. 06
    Football Ogden: Stars aligning for Pochettino to join Manchester United – ESPN Video 1 lexime · 9 hours ago
Similar articles
Opinion

Firing a manager is often more about maintaining the illusion of control | Premier League | The Guardian

He just had to go. His position had become untenable. He’d run out of time, out of credit,…

• 10 hours ago • 6 min read
Opinion

The Guardian view on Jensen Huang’s affair: why did Trump ignore the warnings? | Editorial | The Guardian

It could be the plot of a spy thriller. One of the most powerful figures in the AI…

• 1 day ago • 4 min read
Opinion

‘The light of dawn is on the horizon’: the best moments from US midterm victory speeches | Ted Widmer | The Guardian

As the US election returns came in throughout the night on Tuesday, there was ebullience at the size…

• 2 days ago • 8 min read
VA-NEWS VA-NEWS

Modern portal of reliable, independent and multilingual news. Accurate information, every day.

  • Health
  • Lifestyle
  • News
    • World
  • Opinion
  • Sport
    • Football
  • uncategorized
  • © 2026 VA News. Made with ♥ in Albania
    ⌂ Home ◷ Latest

    Powered by CookieAdmin
    Necessary cookies enable essential site features like secure log-ins and consent preference adjustments. They do not store personal data.
    None
    Functional cookies support features like content sharing on social media, collecting feedback, and enabling third-party tools.
    None
    Analytical cookies track visitor interactions, providing insights on metrics like visitor count, bounce rate, and traffic sources.
    None
    Advertisement cookies deliver personalized ads based on your previous visits and analyze the effectiveness of ad campaigns.
    None
    Unclassified cookies are cookies that we are in the process of classifying, together with the providers of individual cookies.
    None
    Powered by CookieAdmin