Kalo te përmbajtja
  • EN
  • SQ
  • IT
  • FR
  • ES
  • DE
  • EL
VA-NEWS VA-NEWS
  • Home
  • News
  • Opinion
  • Health
  • Technology
  • Sport
  • Lifestyle
  • Entertainment
  • Travel
LIVE
Navigation

VA-NEWS

  • Home
  • News
  • Opinion
  • Health
  • Technology
  • Sport
  • Lifestyle
  • Entertainment
  • Travel
Shortcuts
Home Latest
LIVE
Gjuha
  • EN
  • SQ
  • IT
  • FR
  • ES
  • DE
  • EL

Search news

  1. Kryefaqja
  2. Opinion
  3. Could you predict which children will be Neets? No – and it’s unfair to ask that of teachers | Daisy Christodoulou | The Guardian
Opinion

Could you predict which children will be Neets? No – and it’s unfair to ask that of teachers | Daisy Christodoulou | The Guardian

• August 12, 2026 • 6 min read • 👁 7
◉ WhatsApp 𝕏 X
News

When you go to the dentist, what do you expect? That they will check your teeth, see if you need any fillings, give you some advice on oral hygiene? You probably don’t expect that they will teach your child to read, tackle youth unemployment or solve poverty.

But when it comes to education, politicians are remarkably relaxed about loading wider social responsibilities on to schools. The suggestion from Alan Milburn, a former minister and now a senior government adviser, is that primary schools – that is, schools that educate children aged four to 11 – should identify children who might not be in education, employment or training at the age of 16. “The warning signs are there from a very early, early age. You know, frankly from preschool,” he said. “So, definitely primary schools should be identifying children who are at risk of being Neet. And secondary schools and other services should be intercepting, intervening, supporting and helping those young people to get on a different path.”

Laudable in theory, but we need a bit of realism about what it is fair to make schools responsible for, and if making them responsible for so many things is going to cause more problems than it solves.

Read more:Public transit is a lifeline for countless Americans. Trump is derailing our protections | Lateefah Simon and Guillermo Mayer | The Guardian

Defenders of this approach will argue that big problems have many causes, so we need a holistic response that breaks down institutional silos. I’d argue that by making people responsible for outcomes they have very little control over, you risk demoralising them and distracting them from what they can control.

Of course, it is true that primaries, and secondaries as well, have some influence over students’ later career prospects. There are numerous studies showing the importance of numeracy and literacy to economic outcomes. Getting GCSE English and maths means a student will be much less likely to be Neet. In fact, if a primary did want to create a “Neet risk register”, the simplest thing to do would be to list the pupils struggling to read.

Read more:How to feel optimistic in the face of crisis? Ask the kids fighting slug-like aliens | Alexander Hurst | The Guardian

But that just shows the futility of this kind of policy. The main way a primary school can contribute to a pupil’s future work success is by teaching them maths and English. Requiring a separate Neet strategy would add another layer of bureaucracy to a system that is already too full of them. A boy who is struggling to read shouldn’t need a “potentially unemployed in 2034” database tag before a school can act.

We also need to recognise that while schools have influence over students’ later success, they are just one small part of a wider system. Having better basic skills and more qualifications will help individuals succeed in the labour market. But if there are persistent structural problems with the labour market, improving individuals’ skills will not necessarily create more or better opportunities overall.

Our new government disagrees. They see rising youth unemployment rates as largely education’s problem. It isn’t just Milburn: the new education secretary, Lucy Powell, has suggested a causal link between schools policy and Neet rates, and this analysis is being used to justify radical reform, or as she puts it “rewiring the entire education system to give young people from all backgrounds the chance to thrive”. But is that link true? Neet rates have risen in England and Wales, despite them having very different education systems. The tax and regulatory burden of employing young people has increased in the past few years, and this may have contributed to the sudden rise in Neets over and above what goes on in schools.

Read more:Montréal signs ex-Arsenal, United star Alexis Sánchez

More broadly, we need to look at systemic issues with the British economy. A recent analysis by John Burn-Murdoch in the Financial Times showed that US workers who are functionally illiterate earn as much as the average British worker. “The same proportion of US workers who score stunningly low on literacy earn an average of almost $30 per hour, and two-thirds of them are in work,” he said. “Their British counterparts make the equivalent of $20 and fewer than half are employed.”

Schools can make sure students have the skills they need to thrive in a modern economy, but the economy has to be set up to take advantage of those skills. Increasingly, ours is not. We need to look at all the factors other than skills that might be contributing to this: housing, energy, transport, tax, regulation, health.

Read more:Darwin Núñez prematurely reveals Ronald Araújo Liverpool move before club announcement

And we need to be careful: if we keep improving skills without increasing opportunities, we risk creating a generation of smart but disillusioned young people, youngsters who worked hard at school and university but still ended up with worse living standards than their parents and their peers in other countries.

Over the past 20 years, the UK has barely seen any per capita GDP growth, or any growth in median wages. In the same period, primary schools in England have risen up the rankings on international tests: according to the most recent rankings in 2021, England is one of the best-performing countries in the west on Pirls, a test of primary literacy. Primaries are a rare example of an English public policy success. We risk undermining that success by making them compensate for state failures elsewhere.

Read more:Gianni Infantino calls emergency FIFA staff meeting as pressure grows – report

More broadly, why is it that a holistic approach to a social problem generally requires schools to take on extra responsibilities? “Joined-up government” always seems to involve schools helping the Treasury and Home Office achieve their objectives, not Treasury officials and police officers teaching eight-year-olds to read and count.

Schools are already doing a good job. Some other parts of the British state need to get better at doing theirs.

Read also
Opinion

If Democrats want to win, blue-collar populists are the key | Dustin Guastella and Jared Abbott | The Guardian

Opinion

After a blue wave, Trump will dig in his heels. We must be more vigilant than ever | Steve Cohen and Michael Shank | The Guardian

Tags: #Ask #Children #Employment #Energy #England #Financial times #Gdp #Has #Health

Journalist

From the same category
  • If Democrats want to win, blue-collar populists are the key | Dustin Guastella and Jared Abbott | The Guardian
  • After a blue wave, Trump will dig in his heels. We must be more vigilant than ever | Steve Cohen and Michael Shank | The Guardian
  • The Guardian view on the Trump, Xi and Putin meeting: it may be a first, but it’s not progress | Editorial | The Guardian
  • Should JD Vance run for president? I say go for it, habibi! | Arwa Mahdawi | The Guardian
  • Two reasons Democrats can overcome infighting next year | Robert Reich | The Guardian
From the same tags
  • Ballon d’Or winner Harry Kane out a ‘few months’ after ankle injury
  • Aging: 4-part structured lifestyle program boosts brain health
  • USMNT player ratings: Christian Pulisic gets 9 in Pochettino’s perfect farewell
  • Creatine for longevity: Does science back its muscle, brain benefits?
  • After a blue wave, Trump will dig in his heels. We must be more vigilant than ever | Steve Cohen and Michael Shank | The Guardian
Më të lexuarat — 48h
  1. 01
    Football Ballon d’Or winner Harry Kane out a ‘few months’ after ankle injury 6 lexime · 9 hours ago
  2. 02
    Health Creatine for longevity: Does science back its muscle, brain benefits? 2 lexime · 1 day ago
  3. 03
    Football USMNT player ratings: Christian Pulisic gets 9 in Pochettino’s perfect farewell 2 lexime · 1 day ago
  4. 04
    Health Aging: 4-part structured lifestyle program boosts brain health 2 lexime · 9 hours ago
  5. 05
    Opinion After a blue wave, Trump will dig in his heels. We must be more vigilant than ever | Steve Cohen and Michael Shank | The Guardian 1 lexime · 1 day ago
  6. 06
    Opinion If Democrats want to win, blue-collar populists are the key | Dustin Guastella and Jared Abbott | The Guardian 1 lexime · 10 hours ago
Similar articles
Opinion

If Democrats want to win, blue-collar populists are the key | Dustin Guastella and Jared Abbott | The Guardian

Democrats had a huge night on 3 November. The party ran an average of about 15 points ahead…

• 10 hours ago • 6 min read
Opinion

After a blue wave, Trump will dig in his heels. We must be more vigilant than ever | Steve Cohen and Michael Shank | The Guardian

Americans just witnessed a blue tsunami in the midterm elections, with historic firsts across many US states: the…

• 1 day ago • 5 min read
Opinion

The Guardian view on the Trump, Xi and Putin meeting: it may be a first, but it’s not progress | Editorial | The Guardian

“Historic” is a neutral descriptor, not a favourable one. Things can be unprecedented for good reason. Donald Trump’s…

• 2 days ago • 4 min read
VA-NEWS VA-NEWS

Modern portal of reliable, independent and multilingual news. Accurate information, every day.

  • Health
  • Lifestyle
  • News
    • World
  • Opinion
  • Sport
    • Football
  • uncategorized
  • © 2026 VA News. Made with ♥ in Albania
    ⌂ Home ◷ Latest

    Powered by CookieAdmin
    Necessary cookies enable essential site features like secure log-ins and consent preference adjustments. They do not store personal data.
    None
    Functional cookies support features like content sharing on social media, collecting feedback, and enabling third-party tools.
    None
    Analytical cookies track visitor interactions, providing insights on metrics like visitor count, bounce rate, and traffic sources.
    None
    Advertisement cookies deliver personalized ads based on your previous visits and analyze the effectiveness of ad campaigns.
    None
    Unclassified cookies are cookies that we are in the process of classifying, together with the providers of individual cookies.
    None
    Powered by CookieAdmin